Packaging of meat and meat products has always been challenging because of the perishable nature of the product. As a result, the packaging market must continue the race toward finding more new and innovative ways, write V. Pathak, Z.F. Bhat, S.A.A. Bukhari, S.K. Kotwal, and R.R. Kumar


The packaging is a scientific method of preserving the quality and safety of the food it contains from the time of manufacture to the time it is used by the consumer and also to display the product in the most attractive manner for consumer preference. The ability to convince a potential buyer to use a given product has always been influenced by product packaging and has become an important marketing tool for communicating brand values. Besides protecting the product from physical, chemical, or biological damage (Dallyn and Shorten, 1998), it should also enhance the marketability of the product and be environment friendly (Hurme et al., 2002). The only criterion customers have at the point of purchase of fresh meat cuts is visual appearance. Consequently, desirable meat colour must be maintained during chilled storage, distribution and subsequent retail display if preservative packaging systems are to be effective. In the processed meat products, other factors such as dehydration, lipid oxidation, discolouration, and loss of aroma must be taken into account

Packaging of meat and meat products has always been challenging because of the perishable nature of the product. Today, packaging constitutes an important department of a food processing industry and many meat packaging systems are available with different attributes and applications. These systems range from overwrap packaging for short-term chilled storage and retail display to 100% carbon dioxide atmosphere packaging for long-term chilled storage (Payne et al., 1998). Modern meat packaging technologies include vacuum packaging, modified atmosphere packaging, controlled atmosphere packaging, active packaging, smart packaging, etc. These strive to enhance food safety and quality in a natural way as far as possible (Hotchkiss, 1995). The trends in innovative packaging techniques are discussed in the text that follows.

Packaging Forms and Packaging Materials

Packaging constitutes both flexible and rigid materials, alone or in combination with other preservation methods, to offer the necessary barrier, inactivation, and containment properties required for successful food packaging. Examples of typical flexible packaging materials include polyester, polypropylene, polyethylene, polyvinyl, polyolefins, vinylidene, vinyl chloride, surlyn, or nylon, which provide the needed characteristics such as strength, permeability, and saleability in the food industry (Cutter, 2002; Stollman et al., 1994). Additionally, flexible packaging materials can be combined with gaseous environments to extend the shelf life of many foods, including meat and poultry. Besides synthetically derived packaging materials, flexible packaging can encompass the use of edible films, gels, or coatings made from polysaccharides, proteins, lipids, or composites of any or all three. The benefits of using edible films as packaging materials are threefold: these films may resist the migration of outer moisture into the food during storage; films may serve as gas and solute barriers; and films compliment other types of packaging by improving the quality and shelf life of foods (Ooraikul, 1991). And finally, the combination of rigid packaging materials made from metal, glass, or plastic and combined with heat, provides the most effective and widely used method of food preservation. Tables 1 and 2 show various traits of materials used in the packaging of meat. Nearly all-available films for meat packaging are of thermoplastic materials, and therefore heat seal able, resulting in hermetically sealed plastic pouches, bags, etc. A high oxygen barrier is important in the application of films for packaging meat and meat products. Films made of polyvinylchloride (PVC), polyethylene (PE) or polypropylene (PP) have a relatively high oxygen permeability, whereas polyvinylidene chloride (PVDC), polyester (PETP), polyamide (PA) and cellulose film (ZG) are less or almost non-permeable to oxygen. The latter materials are therefore better suited for packaging meat and meat products. However, the materials of the first group are frequently used as laminates with materials of the second group in order to achieve special effects regarding mechanical strength, heat sealing properties or making the package practically impermeable to both oxygen and water vapour.

Packaging Techniques

The choice of packaging systems and the use depend on many factors including cost, the volume of product being handled, and presentation. Some of the recent methods used in the meat industry are:

Vacuum Packaging

Vacuum packaging refers to packaging in containers (rigid or flexible), from which substantially all air has been removed prior to the final sealing of the container. This method of packaging is actually a form of “modified atmosphere” since normal air is removed from the package. The various advantages of vacuum packaging are that these extend shelf life by controlling oxidative rancidity and by preventing the growth of normal spoilage bacteria (aerobic organisms such as pseudomonas are suppressed and lactic acid bacteria are favoured which can grow to high numbers without causing spoilage), reduce freezer burn and loss of moisture at product surface, require minimum storage space and Leakers are easily detected (small puncture or pin hole in a vacuum pack is easily detected by looking for loose packages).

Today vacuum packaging is the most widely used method employed to extend the storage life of fresh meat (Bell and Garout, 1994). The air within the package must be evacuated to normal anoxic levels i.e. less than 500ppm to prevent browning due to residual oxygen. The exclusion of oxygen from meat surface immediately after carcass is broken into primals preserves the meat’s potential to re-oxygenate soon after retail pack display (Walsh and Kerry, 2002) The preservative effect of vacuum packaging is by inhibition of potent spoilage bacteria at normal meat pH under optimum vacuum packaged conditions (Gill, 1991). The microenvironment within the pack will determine the type of micro-flora, which develops (Devore and Solberg, 1974). When meat is first vacuum packaged any residual oxygen remaining in the pack is consumed by meat and muscle pigments (Hood and Mead, 1993) and CO2 is produced as an end product of tissue and microbial respiration. Under a good vacuum the package head space consists of <1% O2 and 10-20% CO2 (Lambert et al., 1991) which restricts the growth of aerobic microorganisms such as pseudomonas and favours desirable facultative anaerobic organisms such as lactobacillus but also undesirable Bronchothrix thermosphacta. These slow growing bacteria cause less offensive types of spoilage even at higher bacterial numbers than other aerobic organisms and will eventually cause spoilage but only after many weeks of storage. If vacuum packaging procedures are followed correctly, the storage life of meat can be extended (Muller, 1990).

Care must be taken to keep initial bacterial load as low as possible by following strict hygienic procedures. The temperature must be maintained at or near 0-degree Celsius (Brody, 1989). High pH and DFD meat must be avoided as early spoilage may occur (Humphreys, 1996). High vacuum levels result in the most desirable muscle colour and fat appearance. Vacuum packaged meat of normal pH (<5.8) can be stored for 12 (Eustace, 1989) to 14 weeks (Hood and Mead, 1993) at Oo C. However, vacuum packaging is considered unsuitable for red meats for retail display purposes since the oxygen-depleted atmosphere causes the meat in these packages to appear purplish in colour and therefore not acceptable to consumers. Vacuum packaging is ineffective for whole carcasses or cuts which prevent the packaging film being closely applied to all surfaces (Gill, 1991; Gill, 1996). There are four basic ways; the first one involves the use of heat shrinking flexible packaging material around the primal cuts. When exposed to heat it shrinks and increases film thickness, improves mechanical resistance and reduces the drip loss. The second type involves the use of preformed plastic bags/pouches made up of polyamide (PA) as the outer layer, while the inner core is polyethylene (PE). Polyamide provides barrier properties and physical strength while polyethylene provides sealing properties. The third type provides the use of thermoforming trays in line from a base web. Here the product is placed into the tray and then a film web is allowed to cover the tray from a second reel of film followed by pack evaluation and vacuum sealing. The fourth type is vacuum skin packaging, in which the meat is placed in a rigid preformed tray or on the flat surface of a flexible base material followed by heat softening, evacuation and vacuum shrink sealing (Zagory, 1997).

Gas packaging

Gas packaging can be defined as the alteration of the proportional volumes of the gases, which comprise a normal atmosphere. This type of packaging generally falls into two categories:

a) Modified Atmosphere Packaging (MAP)
Refers to enclosing a product in some type of barrier and modifying the atmosphere either by drawing a vacuum or filling with a gas mix. During storage the level of these gases will change due to respiration of the product and permeability of the film.

b) Controlled Atmosphere Packaging
A system where gases are added or removed to maintain a desired balance is called controlled atmosphere packaging. In this case the bulk bin or the storage vessel is virtually impermeable.

Advantages of Gas Packaging

Advantages of gas packaging arethat it allows meat to bloom (if the oxygenated red colour is desired, blend incorporated oxygen can be used to control colour), extends shelf life by controlling oxidation by displacing the oxygen with CO2 and N2 inhibits growth of normal aerobic spoilage organisms besides surface molds, prevents crushing of soft products as gas mixtures of CO2 and N2 equalize the pressure in the package and prevent package collapse and retains moisture but water can move from centre of product to surface resulting in staling.

In MAP systems each gas has a specific role to play in extending the shelf life and maintaining the appearance of packaged meat (Young et al, 1988). The most commonly used gases for the packaging of meat is CO2, N2 and O2 although other gases including CO, N2O, Argon, SO2 and Ozone have been tried to a limited extent (Church, 1994). The most commonly used gas mixture for fresh red meat is high O2, which has a minimum 60-70% O2 and 30-40% CO2 (Walsh and Kerry, 2002). Packaging in high oxygen extends the time for occurrence of microbiological spoilage and discolouration of meat (Sorheim and Nissen, 2000). Most chilled poultry products are sold in prewrapped O2 permeable film, which prevents moisture loss and the spread of contaminating microorganisms. However, where O2 impermeable films are used, mainly for duck and turkey, the benefits are in extended shelf life (Hood and Mead, 1993). There are also reports that high CO2 atmosphere packaging of poultry extends the storage life up to three times that of storage in air (Baker et al., 1985). The modified atmosphere packaging for cured meat products has generated certain problems viz colour stability of cured meat products stored under illumination during retail display. Light exposure including intensity of light or illuminance, oxygen transmission rate of packaging material and residual level of O2 have been found to effect the colour stability of cured meats (Anderson et al., 1988; Yen et al., 1988; Moller et al., 2002).

Discolouration in controlled atmosphere packaging can be prevented only by exclusion of all O2 from the package, which requires special evacuation equipment and totally gas impermeable packaging materials (Gill, 1991). If CO2 is a major or sole component of the input atmosphere, then the quantity of added gas must be adjusted to assure that the intended atmosphere persists after dissolution of the gas into the product (Gill, 1995). For chilled meat, the most effective technology to date is the high CO2 controlled atmosphere packaging system. This regime limits microbial deterioration through optimal storage temperatures (-1.5°C), high levels of CO2, low residual O2 (=0.05%), and use of a gas impermeable film (Jeremiah et al., 1995).

Active and Intelligent Packaging

An active or intelligent packaging is a packaging, which has an additional desired role that improves the quality of the food product as a supplement to pure packaging properties. These properties can either be integrated in the packaging material or separated from it. Intelligent packaging contains an external or internal indicator for the active product history and quality. It has an inherent ability to gather information on its operating environment or history, to process that information in order to draw intelligent inferences from it and to act on those inferences by changing its characteristics in an advantageous manner. Active packaging has an extra function in addition to that of providing a protective barrier against external influence. It can control, and even react to, phenomena taking place inside the package. It actively and constantly changes either package permeation properties or the concentration of various volatiles and gases in the package headspace during storage, or actively adds microbial, antioxidative or other quality improving agents, e.g., flavour enhancing substances, via packaging material into food in small amounts during storage. Examples of active packaging are those that exhibit preferential permeability; temperature compensating attributes; oxygen, carbon dioxide, alcohol, or ethylene scavenging systems; moisture absorbers; antimicrobials incorporated directly into the packaging matrix; controlled release of colourants, flavors, spices, minerals, antimicrobials, ethanol, or antioxidants; or the ability to absorb odors (Labuza and Breene, 1989; Rooney, 1995). Based on their way of functioning, active packaging are categorized into four groups viz scavengers, emitters, indicators and others. The first three types can be evaluated as groups, because of the similarities in the intended function of the product but for other types (e.g. Susceptor materials) of active packaging, an individual evaluation will have to be done from case to case.

Active packaging scavengers

Active packaging scavengers consist of ingredients, which are intended to absorb, remove and then eliminate substances, such as oxygen, ethylene, moisture, or taint from the interior of a food package. The constituents of active packaging material and articles have an effect on the shelf life or the organoleptic properties of the food. The examples are the oxygen scavengers and ethylene scavengers, which are used for eliminating oxygen and ethylene respectively from the package resulting in an extended shelf life of the food. Commercial oxygen scavengers are in most cases based on iron powder, which, in the presence of oxygen, forms iron oxide. Non-metallic and organo-metallic compounds have also been developed.

Active packaging Indicators

Various indicators viz indicators for temperature, microbial spoilage, package integrity, physical shock, and product authenticity etc can give information on the quality of the food product directly, besides the package and its headspace gases, as well as on the storage conditions of the package. Some indicators do not need to interact with the product or the headspace, while others do. These indicators are often called intelligent packaging and certain concepts are already commercially available, and their uses seem to be increasing. New concepts of leak indicators and freshnessindicators are patented, and it can be expected that new commerciallyavailable products will be available in the near future.

Antimicrobial agents:

Quite recently, the idea of incorporating antimicrobial agents directly into packaging films has been developed. Thus, the packaging material can serve as a source of releasing preservatives or antimicrobial agents, or even prevent the growth of microorganisms. Flores and others (1997) reviewed the products and patents in the area of active packaging and identified antimicrobial packaging as one of the most promising versions of an Active Packaging system. Of the active packaging applications, the incorporation and/or slow release of antimicrobials is receiving considerable attention as a means of extending the bacterial lag phase, slowing the growth rate of microorganisms, prolonging shelf life, and maintaining food safety. The general premise of antimicrobial packaging is a controlled migration of the compound to the food through diffusion or partitioning (Han, 2000), which not only allows for initial inhibition of undesirable microorganisms, but also retains residual activity over time.

Active packaging emitters

This group of active packaging contains, or produces, substances, which are meant to migrate into the food packaging headspace or into the food in order to obtain a technological effect in the atmosphere in the packaging or in the food itself as e.g.,
food additives, flavourings or biocides. In these cases, the consumer together with the food ingests the components.

Edible films

Considerable research has been conducted to develop and apply bio-based polymers mainly from a variety of agricultural commodities and /or waste of food products to reduce the amount of synthetic polymer waste. Edible coatings and films offer a variety of advantages such as biodegradability, edibility, biocompatibility, aesthetic appearance, and barrier properties (Han, 2000). The benefits of using edible films as packaging materials are threefold. Since the water activity (aw) is critical for microbial, chemical, and enzymatic activities, edible films may resist the migration of outer moisture into the food during storage. They may serve as gas and solute barriers and compliment other types of packaging by improving the quality and shelf life of foods (Wong et al., 1994). With the incorporation of antimicrobials into the matrix, edible gels, films, or coatings can exhibit active packaging characteristics, which are attributes necessary for controlling undesirable microbes in muscle foods. Antimicrobial compounds such as organic acids (acetic, propionic, benzoic, sorbic, lactic, lauric), potassium sorbate, bacteriocins (nisin, lacticin), grape seed extracts, spice extracts (thymol, p-cymene, cinnamaldehyde), thiosulfinates (allicin), enzymes (peroxidase, lysozyme), proteins (conalbumin), isothiocyanates (allylisothicyanate), antibiotics (imazalil), fungicides (benomyl), chelating agents (EDTA), metals (silver), or parabens (heptylparaben) can be added to edible films to reduce bacteria in solution, on culture media, or on a variety of muscle foods. The incorporated antimicrobial agents must be edible food grade compounds since they have to be consumed along with the edible gels, films, or coatings (Han, 2000; Cutter, 2002; Han, 2002).

Biopolymers

Research efforts since 1940s have been devoted to develop bio-based polymer films derived from natural sources such as plant and animal materials. The use of plant material to form films is an active research topic (Jane et al., 1996). The advantages of using biopolymers for food packaging include: reduced dependence on petroleum-based packaging, use of a renewable agricultural resourcethe biopolymers can act as carriers to deliver shelf-life extenders such as antimicrobials or antioxidants, and biodegradability. Since the forming of a film requires cross-linking of molecular units to impart strength and flexibility, proteins and carbohydrates are often the best candidates for biopolymer films. Proteins investigated include wheat gluten, corn zein, whey, pea protein, meat proteins, egg proteins, and soy. Starches studied in the literature include alginate, polysaccharides, cellulose, carrageenans, and microbial polysaccharides. Pearce and Lavers (1949) reported using carrageenan to protect frozen poultry and Klose et al. (1952) incorporated an antioxidant into a gelatin coating to slow the development of oxidative rancidity in cut poultry meat prior to freezing. Edible film packaging of meat act as a moisture barrier, oxygen barrier, texture modifier, breading adhesion aid, mold suppressor, bacterial inhibitor, physical protectant, oil barrier, antimicrobial carrier and antioxidant carrier. The colour stability of freshly cut beef surfaces has been reported to improve by exposing the meat surface to antioxidant-impregnated corn zein films (Moore et al., 2002).

Conclusions

The purpose of packaging is not only to preserve the quality and safety of the product it contains from the time of manufacture, but also to the time the consumer uses it. An equally important function of packaging is to protect the product from damage due to physical, chemical, or biological hazards, which can be attained through different types of packaging. The need to package foods in a versatile manner for transportation and storage, along with the increasing consumer demand for fresh, convenient, and safe food products presages a bright future for antimicrobial packaging. However, more information is required on the chemical, microbiological and physiological effects of these systems on the packaged food especially on the issues of nutritional quality and human safety. It is likely that future research into a combination of naturally-derived antimicrobial agents, biopreservatives and biodegradable packaging materials will highlight a range of the merits of active packaging in terms of food safety, shelf-life and environmental friendliness (Dallyn and Shorten, 1998; Floros et al 1997; Nicholson 1998; Rodrigues and Han 2000). The challenge continues to finding new and innovative ways to get its message across to buyers, in a world where product price reduction and pressures to lower packaging manufacturing costs are a brutal reality due to globalization. As a result, the packaging market must continue the race toward finding more new and innovative ways to get its message across.

ALSO READ: